a novel idea

[capesams]

with all the new plug builder's today reproducing old shape's reguardless of the difference in size or not having spinner's or lip's or whatever being left off of the new shape..how about giving the original designer and builder , who also already gave it a name some credit....I'm seeing alot of old shape's being made today that being given a [pull name outta the hat] type thing...with all due respect to the new builder's it's nice to put your own label on something,,but call them what they are..a danny's a danny...atom atom...creek chub wigglefish...creek chub minnow....gibbs pencil popper....gibbs jointed.....then your own created name....some already are which shows respect to those who came before them.

[Flaptail]

Never did otherwise. Anybody specifically or just in general? Nothin' being done that ain't been done before anyways.

[Slipknot]

Originally Posted by capesams

with all the new plug builder's today reproducing old shape's reguardless of the difference in size or not having spinner's or lip's or whatever being left off of the new shape..how about giving the original designer and builder , who also already gave it a name some credit....I'm seeing alot of old shape's being made today that being given a [pull name outta the hat] type thing...with all due respect to the new builder's it's nice to put your own label on something,,but call them what they are..a danny's a danny...atom atom...creek chub wigglefish...creek chub minnow....gibbs pencil popper....gibbs jointed.....then your own created name....some already are which shows respect to those who came before them.

I don't get what you're saying?

[fishaholic18]

Originally Posted by Slipknot

I don't get what you're saying?

Give credit where credit is due? I think.

[Slipknot]

so when I make a plug and post a picture of it I should say this is my version of a Hickey-doo and I call it a tantalizer.??

I don't sell plugs so why should I come up with a name for a plug?

I don't get it

I understand respect but if I make a plug like something old and I don't know the history of it, what am I supposed to do to give credit where credit is due, research it?

I just turn hunks of wood into stuff that I want to catch fish on.

[redneck24]

beat a dead horse

[redneck24]

here's a novel idea, why dont we find a new subject to dwell on, this one is getting old.

[IFG]

two changes and it's legal

[missing link]

you rock red neck #24
ML SR

[Nebe]

Ive said it once and i'll say it agian. there are those who are innovative, and there are those who follow. There are those who are original and there are those who are un-original.

Those who copy are only stealing from thier own future.

[Tagger]

Maybe I took this post to lightly ,, some of the comments ,there seems to be an old/new guy division . Maybe also a little commercial builder/hobbyist division on boards also ..The best part of this hobby has been the journey, not the finish line.. I honor the history of each builders place in time and admire there pre-internet craftsmanship.. I don't want to disrespect what came before me because I've learned and enjoyed so much from it . Besides the 2 groups I mentioned above old/new ,, commercial /hobbyist,, There is also a third group among us,, Collector/Historian ,, These are the guys who keep it real and when we think we reinvented the wheel . They give us a history lesson .. I personally have always been drawn to the history of these salty old bastages and feel I'm better for it .. To each his own .. A meal with all the fixens or fast food .. Capesams ,,,I hear you barking big dog ..

[BigFish]

I think anyone who started building automobiles should give props to the inventor.....Henry Ford and name all their vehicles fords.

After all....they are all shaped "about" the same and have wheels just like his....but are they really that different?

Eben....are you following in the grand tradition of rubber eel making or do you feel you are breaking new ground?

[BigFish]

PS....not looking for a pissing contest but just trying to make a point....this is an old topic rehashed many times......how many different ways can you make a wooden stick with hooks on it?

So you don't get angry at me Eben...I was just making a point....I think your rubber eels are very cool, tastey looking and different than any I have seen......but still shaped like a rubber eel with a different twist to the character of the body...and I love it.

I can tell you this.....I do try to make my plugs a bit different than anything I have seen.....but that in itself is difficult. I make a danny...I call it a danny....I make a pencil...its different than Gibbs but still it is a pencil. I feel as though I am going in circles.

The water in this toilet is warm....come on in!

[BigFish]

Also....I will say what I think many are afraid to say....if we have lost many "great builders" from this site I think it is due to their inflated heads and their imagined lofty stature in the plug building world!

Move over cause BigFish likes building plugs....like it or not!

[Slipknot]

Originally Posted by Nebe

Ive said it once and i'll say it agian. there are those who are innovative, and there are those who follow. There are those who are original and there are those who are un-original.

Those who copy are only stealing from thier own future.

well that is your opinion which you are entitled to have.
some do both.

as far as copying is stealing from the future, ya, roll on the floor,
if you mean copying plugs is stealing from your future, well, you'll need to go a little deeper into an explanation of that unless your just joining PNG in stiring.

I think there are leaders and there are followers in life, that is true.

I think plenty of members here give credit where credit is due so I don't see any need for a novel idea.


Steve, sorry to see you think this place has gone down the toilet is it anything specific that makes you think that way? You seem to think people are not calling a danny plug a danny etc.? I have not noticed any of that myself. I guess I am not very observant maybe tagger can clue me in.

[BigFish]

Bravo Sir Slipknot....keeper of the site!

[NIB]

I don't make enough plugs to qualify as a copier.
Slip=Crankenstien.
Everyone wants to be a big plugbuilder.
There's barely any one on here that hasn't dreamed of turnin the plug that they can sell thousands of.
Ralf Cramdon's get Rich quick schemes.
Perhaps sometimes some recognition should be paid.
Consider this. If I was sellin a canal special although I apreciate what Stan or whoever has done in the design dept.to thank him might lead my sales elsewhere's.So I would call it The Outlaw Or Big Bluto.
Metal Lip has all kinds o funny names for his Beachmaster plugs.
Its the way of the world man Not all cars are called Ford's.
Although I don't neccesarrilay agree wit capesams Idea I give due respect.I appreciate the past.I certainly think That he is entitled to his opinions an deserves more respect than what was desplayed on some of the post's I read.
I GOT A NOVEL IDEA hOW BOUT I STICK MY BOOT IN SOME WISE ASSES.

[fishaholic18]

Originally Posted by Slipknot

well that is your opinion which you are entitled to have.
some do both.

as far as copying is stealing from the future, ya, roll on the floor,
if you mean copying plugs is stealing from your future, well, you'll need to go a little deeper into an explanation of that unless your just joining PNG in stiring.

I think there are leaders and there are followers in life, that is true.

I think plenty of members here give credit where credit is due so I don't see any need for a novel idea.


Steve, sorry to see you think this place has gone down the toilet is it anything specific that makes you think that way? You seem to think people are not calling a danny plug a danny etc.? I have not noticed any of that myself. I guess I am not very observant maybe tagger can clue me in.

[Nebe]

Originally Posted by Slipknot

if you mean copying plugs is stealing from your future, well, you'll need to go a little deeper into an explanation of that unless your just joining PNG in stiring.

Sure i will ellaborate- If a person copies alot of peoples plugs, and posts pics of his copies, sells his copies, he will be labled as a copycat, and the value of his plugs will never in a million years rival the value of the original builder's plugs. Look at Lefty's plugon Ebay right now- $90 i think?? i dont see any of his flock fetching that much, and furthermore, the bigger the flock of people that copy you, the higher the price you can comand for your work, because you can claim to be the innovator. If a copycat builder had the balls to use is brain and think about why that plug he so badly wants to copy is good, and understands what makes it good, and use some of the elements of that plug, and take elements from 3 other places, presto, he's an innovator and hopefully he will be rewarded for his hard work.
Dont get me wrong even i copy, but i copy as an excercise to understand proceess. I copied some sluggo's so i could duplicate rubber density. Once the density was matched i threw the mold in the dumpster.



Bigfish- I dont make rubber eels.. I have no idea what your talking about

[Canalman]

Eben,

Let's not forget the Dannys you sell and catch fish on... there is nothing original there right? Just a Danny that you copied... just like I copied and everyone else on this site copied? Right?

[Canalman]

Y'know... I take that back... I'm not worried about copycats... plugs are plugs whether they're a totally original creation or an old stand-by named by its name or by some other name... I know what it is, if it catches I'll fish it... bottom line. Lets talk about herring runs or something now eh? It's almost spring and we can put these pissing contests to sleep until next winter.... SMILE

[Nebe]

Originally Posted by Canalman

Eben,

Let's not forget the Dannys you sell and catch fish on... there is nothing original there right? Just a Danny that you copied... just like I copied and everyone else on this site copied? Right?

I call them dannies because they resemble the form- and as far as being copies, not really I never traced an existing blank. the lip is the same diameter as a danny lip, the tail is about 1/2 of that, and its as wide a plug as i can get out of a 2x2 ballister then divide the lenght of a 3' ballister into x amount of plugs and you get the lenght... bingo- instant danny.

AS for selling them, i will probably not spin wood for profit agian.

[Tagger]

Originally Posted by Slipknot

I guess I am not very observant maybe tagger can clue me in.

Many different interrest in the same hobby..
newbees = energy,, passion
old people = some wisdom, between newbe and historian
historian = remembers where we came from,
hobbyist = doesn't care how long it takes to build a plug.
Commercial = trying to make a go of it , maybe one of us.. I will never be a jealous bastagde of these guys,,alot or work ,taken a chance. American way.. God Bless America..
Its all good !!!
May be a little friction between all of above from time-time , Thats where you come in a Slip.. I think Monster Swap and Rookie Swap kept us buisy and quite this winter,, don't believe place is in the toilet . If somebody wants to say "Hey thats a danny" thats there job ..

[NIB]

Ya right,Thats Nice.
Did u see the Pic of my darta.?

[Tagger]

Originally Posted by NIB

Ya right,Thats Nice.
Did u see the Pic of my darta.?

No ... where ? did you see mine ? I call it "The John Phillip Sousa Memorial Darter" , I finally test swam it yesterday,,,comes in like a marching band.. I was on a beach, no current,, after I stopped reeling it went right around in a circle blades still turning .. I'm going to slay bluefish this year ..

[ProfessorM]

Originally Posted by Tagger

hobbyist = doesn't care how long it takes to build a plug.

See Mac there is a category for me.

[NIB]

Tagger nice U have too much time when u start makin odd ball stuff like that u should just make a normal plug an send it too me.
PM Thats my catagory also.

[fishaholic18]

Originally Posted by Nebe

Ive said it once and i'll say it agian. there are those who are innovative, and there are those who follow. There are those who are original and there are those who are un-original.

Those who copy are only stealing from thier own future.

Let's see them originals. Hasn't pretty much everything pretty much a copy of something else? Even in some small way.

[outnumbered]

Nicely said Tagger, I htink you still have room for a little more metal on that thing, maybe a propeller on the front.