Definitely fish it like a needle on those windy crummy nights,,,
IT WILL CATCH..... You can fish it SLOWLY just below the surface or you can let it sink for a few seconds and then reel it SLOWLY just bouncing it along the bottom,,
The night-n-gal was made after the pocket rocket which is a wood version of the No Equal which all three where made to be fished in a sloppy wind in your face spot, I believe the last 2 wood lures were made for Block Island.
I would use different styles until something worked there is no set in stone way to fish any plug