If you want to fish Cuttyhunk.... you better start exercising those legs.

[Swimmer]

I think we should have a fill up the ferry group fishing trip for the spring to the new secret destination. When we arrive we all walk off the ferry like we dont know each other and then meet up at a prearranged "secret spot" to plunder the fishes!

[DJ Muller]

I have fished Cuttyhunk, I have fished the Vineyard, I have fished Jamestown, Montauk, on and on it goes. I have had good nights on the Hunk, but better and "bigger' nights on the Vineyard, on Jamestown, on Montauk too, as well as Jersey. Being in the right place at the right time pays some huge dividends...sometimes. I have also fished some "unbelievable" locales where I have fished a week straight with nothing but dinks. Cuttyhunk is strategically good, but it is not the only "mecca" on the planet. I have come home from there with "little" or nothing. It comes down to...what makes happen for you. the CC canal, the outer Cape, Plum Island...whatever. If you enjoy it and it satisfies you...go for it! And enjoy it. Cuttyhunk is only one of hundreds!