I may not be as "seasoned" as some of you gents, but I have seen a ridicules amount of shows, to pick just one would be too hard...
Lots of things make a show great, the atmosphere, the crowd, the music all play a factor in a show for me.
Some of my best times were at The Dead
Craziest crowd time, Gangster Bitch Barbie
Best Acoustic show Dave Matthews w/ Tim Reynolds at Amherst
Even Motley Crew the Girls, Girls, Girls tour was fun too
Threaded Mode