Quote:
	
	
		| 
					Originally Posted by JohnnyD  I know you aren't and your opinion is very valid.  A fish killed is a fish killed.  Recs can only handle the smaller fish, thus the larger, healthy breeder fish stay somewhat unmolested.  Isn't this the same argument people used with Stripers: "Put those healthy 40# breeders back and only keep smaller fish."
 With some of the people I've encountered, it seems like people are talking out of both sides of their mouth - "Don't take away comm stripers because there is too much take, but it's ok to shut down the recreational tuna take due to being over quota."
 | 
	
 The difference between stripers and tuna is that with stripers, even the smaller fish are breeders, with tuna no fish smaller than about 70 inches has ever had a chance to spawn.